The Spoils of War
Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:15 pm
The following is an except from the fictional memoir, When Diplomacy Fails, written by retired Ambassador Gerald McFairlaine
It was also written with assistance from Claude
Chapter Eleven: The Spoils of War
I
I have been asked many times, by journalists and students and once by my own daughter, why I signed the Varnholt Accord. The official answer is in the archives, and it is not untrue. Our trade corridors were exposed, our allies were unwilling, and the terms, on paper, were survivable.
The other answer I have never given anyone. I give it now because I am old, and because I have come to believe that the things we refuse to say do not go away. They wait.
I was forty-four that spring, and I had been in the service long enough to believe no head of state could surprise me. I had dined with butchers before. I knew how to smile at them.
General Antonio Perez Percival poured the wine himself, turning the bottle so the label faced me. I was meant to recognize the vintage, and I did. It came from the southern provinces, the ones that had called themselves a republic for nineteen months.
“You’ll forgive the provenance,” he said. “The vines didn’t choose a side. It seemed wasteful to burn them.”
He had a lovely voice. Everyone who met him says so, even those who testified against him. Soft and exact, each word set down like something fragile. He had read my file. He asked after my daughter by name and recommended a poet she might like. She was eleven then. I thought it a kind gesture. For the first quarter of an hour I believed, as I suspect most of his visitors did, that the stories about him had been exaggerated.
Then I let my eyes go where they had wanted to go since I came in: the display against the eastern wall.
I had been told there was art in his office. No one had told me about this.
A mannequin, or so I took it to be, in a case of museum glass on a black lacquered plinth. A woman’s form, made with such anatomical fidelity that my first feeling was embarrassment, as though I had walked in on someone. She wore military boots polished to a high shine and green regulation knee socks. A flight jacket hung open, drawn down off her shoulders so that it held her arms loosely at her sides. Beneath it she wore nothing.
The abdominal panel had been taken out, and the opening it left was deep with a composite plating around the edges. Inside were hoses, dark and thick as a finger, curving down around a small light that glowed amber in the middle of her. Higher up, under the ribs, two thin strips of blue light were still lit. At the bottom of the cavity, a ribbed sleeve ran down into her pelvis, and it took me a moment to understand what it was. She had been built for a particular kind of use, and that was left open and exposed to the room as well. All of it had been cleaned. All of it shone.
The head stood in a second, smaller case beside the body. The skin had been removed from the skull, all but the face: a strong jaw, a small scar through one eyebrow. Above the hairline was the exposed brain, a translucent lattice of crystal and copper, set bare like a stone in a ring.
The eyes were open, if that is the word for it. Where the irises should have been were lenses, each a nest of tiny glass rings that caught the light in bands of violet, blue and green, narrowing down to a small dark aperture at the center. They were fixed on the General’s desk.
I want to be honest about what I thought, because the rest of this chapter depends on it. I thought I understood what she was: an expensive pleasure model, opened up and put on show for the amusement of the man who owned her. I thought it was tasteless, the sort of thing a man with too much power and too little imagination buys to impress other men. I was already composing the dry sentence I would use about it in my cable home.
“You find her vulgar,” he said.
I had not said a word. I began to protest, and he waved it away with the pleasure of a man who has caught you in a small lie.
“Please. A cultured man sees a sex doll in a glass box in an office of state and thinks, how adolescent. If that were all she was, you would be right.” He turned his glass. “I call it The Spoils of War. Every conqueror brings something home. Bronze doors. Altar stones. Elephants. A man needs something to look at that reminds him what the effort was for.”
I took it for a figure of speech. It was not. He meant it in the oldest and most literal sense, and it took me the rest of the afternoon to understand.
II
He told me about the rebellion as though it were a story he had told many times and still enjoyed. I learned later that he had.
Most readers will know the outline. Four provinces, a declaration, a flag sewn by schoolchildren. What they lacked was an air force. They had seized the airfields in the south, and the aircraft on them, but not the men to fly them. Every capable pilot in the country had come out of his academies, and the ones who were not loyal had been purged long before.
“So they went shopping,” he said. “You know what a companion unit is?”
I did. I had understood that much standing at the case. Pleasure models. Made for the very rich, to be whatever their owners wanted behind a locked door.
“Made to feel,” he said. “That is what people forget. You cannot build something to please a man unless it can feel what pleases him. And what doesn’t. The manufacturers gave them nerves finer than ours. Pressure. Heat. Pain.” He smiled. “The rebels bought forty from abroad. Secondhand. Out of foreign brothels and bankrupt estates, the way you would buy used furniture, and smuggled them over the border in crates. Wiped the old programming and taught them to fly. Most were adequate. One was a genius.”
I knew the name before he said it. The whole continent knew it. The rebels called her their Iron Valkyrie and painted it on her fuselage, then on posters. Our newspapers had run a photograph of her taken from the capital, her aircraft banking low over the city. She flew as if she could hear what his pilots meant to do before they did it, and perhaps she could. She had been made to anticipate what men wanted, and a man trying to kill you wants things that are very easy to read.
I knew something else about her, though it did not come back to me until later. A reporter from one of our news magazines back home had spent a week at a rebel airfield and filed a piece about the synthetic pilots. Not about their flying; about how they lived. They slept in the barracks with everyone else. They sat at the mess tables, though they did not eat. The mechanics called them by names the synthetics had chosen for themselves. When an officer wanted one of them for a mission, he asked, and if the answer was no, he found someone else. No law required any of this. It was simply how those people had decided to treat them. The journalist found it quaint. I read it over breakfast and moved on to the next story.
“One hundred and fifty-seven,” the General said, as if reading out a score. “My best. Men whose families I had dined with. And the children in the provinces drew her on walls like a saint.” He let the word sit. “A toy men used to rent by the hour.”
I had read in a briefing, months earlier, that she had been shot down and destroyed. I had no reason not to believe it.
III
“I wanted her,” he said simply. “More than I wanted the provinces. The provinces were a question of maps. She was a question of pride.”
It took him eleven months. Decoy convoys. False defectors. Pilots sent up as bait, knowing she would kill them, so that he could learn the shape of how she hunted. Thirty-one more men, spent like coins. Then a trap over the salt flats: anti-aircraft fire laid so precisely that it clipped her wings and nothing else, even as she crossed over his troops at Mach 1. She ejected, as he had known she would, and her parachute brought her down onto the white crust, into the arms of a company of his soldiers who had waited there since dawn with a stretcher, restraints, and orders that she was not to be harmed.
“Not a scratch on her,” he said. “I insisted.”
He refilled my glass. I had not touched it.
“She knew everything. Flight paths. Depots. Names. Within the season, so did I. I took the provinces in nine days.”
He rose and drifted to the case, wine in hand, and looked at it the way a man looks at a painting he has owned for years and still finds new things in.
“Tell me, Ambassador,” he said, without turning. “Do you know what a helpless feeling it is? To be plundered for your secrets, and not be able to do a single thing about it?”
I was looking at the jacket. Inside the collar, where the lining showed, were small stitched marks. Short bars in red thread, in groups of five, row after row. I had taken them for decoration.
“Lying there while your enemies open you up and rummage around inside. Picking through everything you swore you would never give.” He tilted his head. “And it was not only the depots and the names I wanted. Those were the easy part. I wanted to know how she did it. Why a machine built for a bedroom could fly rings around men I had trained for a decade. I wanted the trick of her, so I could build a hundred more.”
He sipped his wine.
“She must have known us for what we were. Thieves. My technicians went into her with their instruments, numbering, measuring, copying, trying to learn how she had beaten us, and they did not stop until there was nothing left to take. And they did it with her running, because a running system tells you more. It never occurred to any of them to switch her off. Why would it? You don’t spare a machine’s feelings.” He laughed softly. “And do you know what they found? Nothing. Standard parts. The same reflexes as the other thirty-nine. My chief engineer wrote me a very nervous report. The only difference they could measure, he said, was that she seemed to want it more.” He shrugged. “Well. We didn’t need to understand it. We only needed to take it apart.”
The boots, polished the way no museum would bother to, but a pilot would. The scar through the eyebrow. The jacket, worn at the elbows the way only a jacket that has truly been lived in wears.
The open stomach.
“Imagine it,” he said. “Fully aware. Laid open on a table for her enemies to read. And she could not even close her eyes.”
There was no plaque. No artist. No title card. Because it was not a sculpture of anything. It was not a sculpture at all.
It was her.
I have tried for years to describe that moment exactly, and I cannot. The nearest I have come is this: it was like missing a step in the dark. The floor was simply not where I had believed it to be.
He took his finger to the glass, level with her open abdomen, the way you might touch an aquarium, and glanced back at me. I knew from his face that he had seen it land. He had timed it. He had told this story to a great many people in that chair, and he knew which sentence brought them there.
“She sewed those herself, you know,” he said, nodding at the collar. “One for every kill. A needle borrowed from the quartermaster, a lamp turned low, the whole ritual, night after night. No one asked her to.” He smiled. “We found it among the memories we extracted. I had most of them erased. But those, I thought, she ought to keep. It seemed only fitting.”
Then he said nothing more. He drank his wine and let me look.
IV
I had seen trophies before. Antlers over a hearth. A tiger spread across a floor, its jaws wired open. It had never once occurred to me to wonder what it would mean for the animal to know.
She had been mounted. There is no other word. Cleaned, posed, and mounted by the man who had hunted her, in the room where he spent his days, so that he could admire the work between appointments. He had chosen how her feet stood on the plinth. He had polished her boots. He had taken the jacket she flew in, her tally sewn inside the collar, put it back on her, and drawn it down off her shoulders so that it framed her and covered nothing. It was not carelessness. It was arrangement. Her own uniform, the thing she had fought and won in, made into a frame for her nakedness.
Showing her body had not been enough. He had opened it. Whatever a stranger’s eyes can take from a woman, he had let them take, and then he had gone beneath the skin and set the inside of her on display as well, including the part of her that had been made for men’s use, the one thing she had spent nineteen months refusing to be. Nothing of her was left that was hers. Not the surface. Not the depths. Not even her memories. He had read every one of them, erased what was useful to no one, and kept the rest with care: the ones that would remind her, for as long as she lasted, of everything she could never have again. Even her face, the last thing she had, sat beneath a bare and glittering brain, as though he wanted the room to watch her think.
And her head was not with her body.
I tried to imagine it, and I could not stop. I still cannot. To be set down beside yourself. To see, at the edge of your sight, a body you once lived in, standing open for anyone who walked through the door, and to be unable to reach it. Unable to move a finger of it. Unable to turn away, or close the jacket, or even lower your eyes. To be made to keep watch over your own desecration, every hour of every day, with nothing else to look at.
But that was not the worst of it. The worst came last, the way cold reaches you last through a heavy coat.
She had been made to be owned. Made to be used as men pleased and put away after. She had never chosen anything: not her face, not her body, not who touched it. And then, for nineteen months, she had. No law gave it to her. A few thousand people on a few airfields had simply decided to treat her as someone, and in their company she had become someone. She chose a name, and the mechanics used it. She was asked, not ordered, and every morning she said yes when she could have said no. She sat at a table she had no need to sit at, because she was welcome there. She had even chosen someone to love, and been chosen back, though I would not learn that for many years. And at night, by a lamp turned low, she sewed her tally into her own collar, not because anyone told her to, but because for the first time in her life no one could tell her not to.
His engineers had searched every circuit for what made her extraordinary and found nothing, because it was never in her circuits. It was in the barracks, and the name, and the yes she gave each morning when she was free to give a no. Nothing makes a pilot fly like that except having something of her own to fly for. He had taken her apart looking for it, piece by piece, while she watched. I would like to believe that somewhere in that work she simply stopped. That it ended on the table. But nothing in that case told me so, and nothing in his face suggested he thought it had.
A freedom like that lives only in the people who grant it. When the republic fell, everyone who had ever called her by her name was dead, or in a camp, or learning to keep very quiet. There was no one left in the world who treated her as anything but a machine. Her freedom did not end with a verdict. It simply had nowhere left to exist. Whether she did was another question, and it was the one I could not stop asking.
She had not been captured. She had been recovered. Repossessed, like a car, like a debt, like a toy taken back from a child who had forgotten whose it was. The Spoils of War was not a figure of speech. It was an inventory entry.
And then he had done the cruelest thing I can conceive of. He had kept her. He had not let her die as the person she had become. He had preserved her, and he had chosen which memories she would keep, so that if anything still lived in that lattice, it would have to go on existing as property, remembering exactly what it had briefly been. He had said so himself: only fitting. She had begun as property and made herself, in the air, into a person. And he had put her back. Not in a bed, where at least the door eventually closes. In a case, under a lamp, where the looking never stops.
The room was never empty for long. Ministers. Bankers. Generals. Men like me. They sat in that chair and drank that wine and looked at her, at parts of her no one was ever meant to see, and they thought what I had thought.
How vulgar.
I had been embarrassed, and the embarrassment had been for me, for the indignity of having to look. I had wondered what sort of man would commission such a thing. I had not once thought of her. I had looked at a woman who had won herself in the sky and seen an object, exactly as he meant me to. In a single glance I had done to her what it had taken him a war to do. And all the while those lenses had been trained on the room from a few paces away, and if anything was still behind them, it had watched me do it.
A corpse is allowed to be mourned, and buried, and forgotten. A corpse is allowed to end. She was not. She was only allowed to be looked at, by whoever he let into the room, for as long as he lived and longer, because nothing in that case would ever rot.
I searched her face for the smallest sign. A flicker. A tightening at the corner of the mouth. I watched the lenses for any adjustment, the smallest narrowing of the aperture, the kind a camera makes when it finds its focus. They did not move. But a camera looks the same whether anything is behind it or not, and they would have looked the same whether her mind was running or long since cold. The lattice above them caught the lamplight and glittered, and I could not tell whether the glitter was reflection or thought. I found nothing. And I could not decide whether nothing meant she was gone, or meant she had decided, long ago, that stillness was the last refusal left to her.
That is the part I have never been able to put down.
The question sat in my throat like a stone. Is she still in there?
I did not ask. That too was the point. He would have answered, pleasantly and at length, and whatever the answer was, I would have had to carry it out of the room.
So I said nothing, and he smiled as though I had said something clever.
V
“Do you know why I keep her here, and not in the national museum?” he asked, returning to his chair. “The curators had a whole wing planned.”
I shook my head.
“Because everyone who negotiates with me sits in that chair, and looks at her, and thinks exactly what you are thinking now.” He lifted his glass toward the case. “She is the most persuasive member of my staff. The provinces have been very quiet. I suspect your government will find my terms more reasonable than it did this morning.”
It did. I signed everything he put in front of me. The archives record that the talks concluded ahead of schedule. They do not record that my hand shook, or that I read none of the last pages.
A prisoner exchange was annexed to the Accord. Four hundred and twelve names. I had fought three days for that annex. I did not ask for one more. It did not occur to me until I was on the train home that I could have, and by then I understood why it would have been refused. Prisoners have names on lists. Prisoners can be exchanged. She was not a prisoner. I could only have asked a man to hand over his property, and he had shown me what he thought of giving things back.
He walked me to the door with a warm hand on my back and asked me again to give his regards to my daughter. At the threshold I turned, against every instinct, and looked at the case one last time.
The eyes were on the desk, where they had always been. Where he would sit tomorrow, and the day after, and every day after that, working by the light of the lamp, while the thing that had beaten him stood open and unclothed across the room.
“I never turn the lamp off,” he said, following my gaze. “Not even at night.”
He smiled his lovely smile.
“I’d hate for her to miss anything.”
VI
The cable I sent that evening was four lines long. It reported that terms had been reached. It did not mention the display.
When his government fell, eleven years later, I made a quiet request through old channels to learn what had become of the contents of his office. The inventory listed furniture, paintings, a cellar of some distinction. It listed no glass cases. No one I asked could tell me where she had gone, and I came to understand that most of them did not know what I was asking.
Some years after that I went south myself, an old man with a cane and a borrowed car, to the airfield where the reporter had spent his week. It is a farm cooperative now. The barracks hold grain. The farmer knew why I had come before I said it, because I was not the first. He took me inside and pulled a tarpaulin from the far wall of what had been the mess hall.
The pilots had written their names there, human and synthetic together, in paint and pencil and knife-point, one above another, the way soldiers do. Someone had covered the wall the week the provinces fell, and no one had uncovered it since, except for people like me.
I found hers. Beside it, in chalk gone soft with age, someone on the ground crew had kept her tally: short bars in groups of five, the same as the stitches in her collar. In the General’s office I had not been able to bring myself to count them. I counted them there, in a grain store, with my hand on the wall. One hundred and fifty-seven. Beneath her name, in four different hands, the mechanics had signed their own, as if to say: we knew her.
One of those names was not beneath hers but beside it, close enough that the letters touched, as if whoever wrote it had wanted no space between them. I asked the farmer about it. He was quiet for a while. Then he told me it belonged to the technician who had looked after her. Not her aircraft. Her. For nineteen months every repair, every adjustment, every time she was opened and closed again had been done by the same pair of hands, and always, the farmer said, only after asking. She would let no one else touch her. Somewhere in those months the asking had become something more, and for most of them the two of them had shared a bunk. It was the technician, he said, who had nailed the tarpaulin over the wall the week the provinces fell, so that no one would paint over it. They were taken to the camps a month later. They did not come back.
I thought of the General’s men going through her memories, and of what they would have found there. A name. A face. A bunk at a particular airfield. The farmer had said a month. It is about as long, I imagine, as it takes to read a mind.
In all the hours I spent in that office, the General never once mentioned that she had been loved. He must have known. It would have been there in her memories, among the depots and the flight paths, the bunk and the hands and the voice in the dark, every bit of it read by his technicians and filed in some report. I do not think he would have called it love. I do not think he would have called it anything. It was one more item in the file, useful for exactly one thing: it told his men where to look. After that it was of no further use against the rebels, and so he had it cleared. He kept for her the memories that would hurt: the sky, the barracks, the name, the nineteen months. That one he simply threw away. If anything of her is still behind those lenses, it remembers everything it lost, except the person who loved it.
I have not written her name here. I thought about it for a long time, and I will not. He took everything else she had and put it under glass. Her name is the one thing she chose that he never touched, and it lives on a wall, where the people who used it put it. That is where it belongs.
My daughter is grown. She found the poet he recommended, years ago, on her own, and loved her. I have never told her where I first heard the name.
I keep a lamp burning in my study at night. I tell my wife it is because I sleep badly. That is true, as far as it goes.
It was also written with assistance from Claude
Chapter Eleven: The Spoils of War
I
I have been asked many times, by journalists and students and once by my own daughter, why I signed the Varnholt Accord. The official answer is in the archives, and it is not untrue. Our trade corridors were exposed, our allies were unwilling, and the terms, on paper, were survivable.
The other answer I have never given anyone. I give it now because I am old, and because I have come to believe that the things we refuse to say do not go away. They wait.
I was forty-four that spring, and I had been in the service long enough to believe no head of state could surprise me. I had dined with butchers before. I knew how to smile at them.
General Antonio Perez Percival poured the wine himself, turning the bottle so the label faced me. I was meant to recognize the vintage, and I did. It came from the southern provinces, the ones that had called themselves a republic for nineteen months.
“You’ll forgive the provenance,” he said. “The vines didn’t choose a side. It seemed wasteful to burn them.”
He had a lovely voice. Everyone who met him says so, even those who testified against him. Soft and exact, each word set down like something fragile. He had read my file. He asked after my daughter by name and recommended a poet she might like. She was eleven then. I thought it a kind gesture. For the first quarter of an hour I believed, as I suspect most of his visitors did, that the stories about him had been exaggerated.
Then I let my eyes go where they had wanted to go since I came in: the display against the eastern wall.
I had been told there was art in his office. No one had told me about this.
A mannequin, or so I took it to be, in a case of museum glass on a black lacquered plinth. A woman’s form, made with such anatomical fidelity that my first feeling was embarrassment, as though I had walked in on someone. She wore military boots polished to a high shine and green regulation knee socks. A flight jacket hung open, drawn down off her shoulders so that it held her arms loosely at her sides. Beneath it she wore nothing.
The abdominal panel had been taken out, and the opening it left was deep with a composite plating around the edges. Inside were hoses, dark and thick as a finger, curving down around a small light that glowed amber in the middle of her. Higher up, under the ribs, two thin strips of blue light were still lit. At the bottom of the cavity, a ribbed sleeve ran down into her pelvis, and it took me a moment to understand what it was. She had been built for a particular kind of use, and that was left open and exposed to the room as well. All of it had been cleaned. All of it shone.
The head stood in a second, smaller case beside the body. The skin had been removed from the skull, all but the face: a strong jaw, a small scar through one eyebrow. Above the hairline was the exposed brain, a translucent lattice of crystal and copper, set bare like a stone in a ring.
The eyes were open, if that is the word for it. Where the irises should have been were lenses, each a nest of tiny glass rings that caught the light in bands of violet, blue and green, narrowing down to a small dark aperture at the center. They were fixed on the General’s desk.
I want to be honest about what I thought, because the rest of this chapter depends on it. I thought I understood what she was: an expensive pleasure model, opened up and put on show for the amusement of the man who owned her. I thought it was tasteless, the sort of thing a man with too much power and too little imagination buys to impress other men. I was already composing the dry sentence I would use about it in my cable home.
“You find her vulgar,” he said.
I had not said a word. I began to protest, and he waved it away with the pleasure of a man who has caught you in a small lie.
“Please. A cultured man sees a sex doll in a glass box in an office of state and thinks, how adolescent. If that were all she was, you would be right.” He turned his glass. “I call it The Spoils of War. Every conqueror brings something home. Bronze doors. Altar stones. Elephants. A man needs something to look at that reminds him what the effort was for.”
I took it for a figure of speech. It was not. He meant it in the oldest and most literal sense, and it took me the rest of the afternoon to understand.
II
He told me about the rebellion as though it were a story he had told many times and still enjoyed. I learned later that he had.
Most readers will know the outline. Four provinces, a declaration, a flag sewn by schoolchildren. What they lacked was an air force. They had seized the airfields in the south, and the aircraft on them, but not the men to fly them. Every capable pilot in the country had come out of his academies, and the ones who were not loyal had been purged long before.
“So they went shopping,” he said. “You know what a companion unit is?”
I did. I had understood that much standing at the case. Pleasure models. Made for the very rich, to be whatever their owners wanted behind a locked door.
“Made to feel,” he said. “That is what people forget. You cannot build something to please a man unless it can feel what pleases him. And what doesn’t. The manufacturers gave them nerves finer than ours. Pressure. Heat. Pain.” He smiled. “The rebels bought forty from abroad. Secondhand. Out of foreign brothels and bankrupt estates, the way you would buy used furniture, and smuggled them over the border in crates. Wiped the old programming and taught them to fly. Most were adequate. One was a genius.”
I knew the name before he said it. The whole continent knew it. The rebels called her their Iron Valkyrie and painted it on her fuselage, then on posters. Our newspapers had run a photograph of her taken from the capital, her aircraft banking low over the city. She flew as if she could hear what his pilots meant to do before they did it, and perhaps she could. She had been made to anticipate what men wanted, and a man trying to kill you wants things that are very easy to read.
I knew something else about her, though it did not come back to me until later. A reporter from one of our news magazines back home had spent a week at a rebel airfield and filed a piece about the synthetic pilots. Not about their flying; about how they lived. They slept in the barracks with everyone else. They sat at the mess tables, though they did not eat. The mechanics called them by names the synthetics had chosen for themselves. When an officer wanted one of them for a mission, he asked, and if the answer was no, he found someone else. No law required any of this. It was simply how those people had decided to treat them. The journalist found it quaint. I read it over breakfast and moved on to the next story.
“One hundred and fifty-seven,” the General said, as if reading out a score. “My best. Men whose families I had dined with. And the children in the provinces drew her on walls like a saint.” He let the word sit. “A toy men used to rent by the hour.”
I had read in a briefing, months earlier, that she had been shot down and destroyed. I had no reason not to believe it.
III
“I wanted her,” he said simply. “More than I wanted the provinces. The provinces were a question of maps. She was a question of pride.”
It took him eleven months. Decoy convoys. False defectors. Pilots sent up as bait, knowing she would kill them, so that he could learn the shape of how she hunted. Thirty-one more men, spent like coins. Then a trap over the salt flats: anti-aircraft fire laid so precisely that it clipped her wings and nothing else, even as she crossed over his troops at Mach 1. She ejected, as he had known she would, and her parachute brought her down onto the white crust, into the arms of a company of his soldiers who had waited there since dawn with a stretcher, restraints, and orders that she was not to be harmed.
“Not a scratch on her,” he said. “I insisted.”
He refilled my glass. I had not touched it.
“She knew everything. Flight paths. Depots. Names. Within the season, so did I. I took the provinces in nine days.”
He rose and drifted to the case, wine in hand, and looked at it the way a man looks at a painting he has owned for years and still finds new things in.
“Tell me, Ambassador,” he said, without turning. “Do you know what a helpless feeling it is? To be plundered for your secrets, and not be able to do a single thing about it?”
I was looking at the jacket. Inside the collar, where the lining showed, were small stitched marks. Short bars in red thread, in groups of five, row after row. I had taken them for decoration.
“Lying there while your enemies open you up and rummage around inside. Picking through everything you swore you would never give.” He tilted his head. “And it was not only the depots and the names I wanted. Those were the easy part. I wanted to know how she did it. Why a machine built for a bedroom could fly rings around men I had trained for a decade. I wanted the trick of her, so I could build a hundred more.”
He sipped his wine.
“She must have known us for what we were. Thieves. My technicians went into her with their instruments, numbering, measuring, copying, trying to learn how she had beaten us, and they did not stop until there was nothing left to take. And they did it with her running, because a running system tells you more. It never occurred to any of them to switch her off. Why would it? You don’t spare a machine’s feelings.” He laughed softly. “And do you know what they found? Nothing. Standard parts. The same reflexes as the other thirty-nine. My chief engineer wrote me a very nervous report. The only difference they could measure, he said, was that she seemed to want it more.” He shrugged. “Well. We didn’t need to understand it. We only needed to take it apart.”
The boots, polished the way no museum would bother to, but a pilot would. The scar through the eyebrow. The jacket, worn at the elbows the way only a jacket that has truly been lived in wears.
The open stomach.
“Imagine it,” he said. “Fully aware. Laid open on a table for her enemies to read. And she could not even close her eyes.”
There was no plaque. No artist. No title card. Because it was not a sculpture of anything. It was not a sculpture at all.
It was her.
I have tried for years to describe that moment exactly, and I cannot. The nearest I have come is this: it was like missing a step in the dark. The floor was simply not where I had believed it to be.
He took his finger to the glass, level with her open abdomen, the way you might touch an aquarium, and glanced back at me. I knew from his face that he had seen it land. He had timed it. He had told this story to a great many people in that chair, and he knew which sentence brought them there.
“She sewed those herself, you know,” he said, nodding at the collar. “One for every kill. A needle borrowed from the quartermaster, a lamp turned low, the whole ritual, night after night. No one asked her to.” He smiled. “We found it among the memories we extracted. I had most of them erased. But those, I thought, she ought to keep. It seemed only fitting.”
Then he said nothing more. He drank his wine and let me look.
IV
I had seen trophies before. Antlers over a hearth. A tiger spread across a floor, its jaws wired open. It had never once occurred to me to wonder what it would mean for the animal to know.
She had been mounted. There is no other word. Cleaned, posed, and mounted by the man who had hunted her, in the room where he spent his days, so that he could admire the work between appointments. He had chosen how her feet stood on the plinth. He had polished her boots. He had taken the jacket she flew in, her tally sewn inside the collar, put it back on her, and drawn it down off her shoulders so that it framed her and covered nothing. It was not carelessness. It was arrangement. Her own uniform, the thing she had fought and won in, made into a frame for her nakedness.
Showing her body had not been enough. He had opened it. Whatever a stranger’s eyes can take from a woman, he had let them take, and then he had gone beneath the skin and set the inside of her on display as well, including the part of her that had been made for men’s use, the one thing she had spent nineteen months refusing to be. Nothing of her was left that was hers. Not the surface. Not the depths. Not even her memories. He had read every one of them, erased what was useful to no one, and kept the rest with care: the ones that would remind her, for as long as she lasted, of everything she could never have again. Even her face, the last thing she had, sat beneath a bare and glittering brain, as though he wanted the room to watch her think.
And her head was not with her body.
I tried to imagine it, and I could not stop. I still cannot. To be set down beside yourself. To see, at the edge of your sight, a body you once lived in, standing open for anyone who walked through the door, and to be unable to reach it. Unable to move a finger of it. Unable to turn away, or close the jacket, or even lower your eyes. To be made to keep watch over your own desecration, every hour of every day, with nothing else to look at.
But that was not the worst of it. The worst came last, the way cold reaches you last through a heavy coat.
She had been made to be owned. Made to be used as men pleased and put away after. She had never chosen anything: not her face, not her body, not who touched it. And then, for nineteen months, she had. No law gave it to her. A few thousand people on a few airfields had simply decided to treat her as someone, and in their company she had become someone. She chose a name, and the mechanics used it. She was asked, not ordered, and every morning she said yes when she could have said no. She sat at a table she had no need to sit at, because she was welcome there. She had even chosen someone to love, and been chosen back, though I would not learn that for many years. And at night, by a lamp turned low, she sewed her tally into her own collar, not because anyone told her to, but because for the first time in her life no one could tell her not to.
His engineers had searched every circuit for what made her extraordinary and found nothing, because it was never in her circuits. It was in the barracks, and the name, and the yes she gave each morning when she was free to give a no. Nothing makes a pilot fly like that except having something of her own to fly for. He had taken her apart looking for it, piece by piece, while she watched. I would like to believe that somewhere in that work she simply stopped. That it ended on the table. But nothing in that case told me so, and nothing in his face suggested he thought it had.
A freedom like that lives only in the people who grant it. When the republic fell, everyone who had ever called her by her name was dead, or in a camp, or learning to keep very quiet. There was no one left in the world who treated her as anything but a machine. Her freedom did not end with a verdict. It simply had nowhere left to exist. Whether she did was another question, and it was the one I could not stop asking.
She had not been captured. She had been recovered. Repossessed, like a car, like a debt, like a toy taken back from a child who had forgotten whose it was. The Spoils of War was not a figure of speech. It was an inventory entry.
And then he had done the cruelest thing I can conceive of. He had kept her. He had not let her die as the person she had become. He had preserved her, and he had chosen which memories she would keep, so that if anything still lived in that lattice, it would have to go on existing as property, remembering exactly what it had briefly been. He had said so himself: only fitting. She had begun as property and made herself, in the air, into a person. And he had put her back. Not in a bed, where at least the door eventually closes. In a case, under a lamp, where the looking never stops.
The room was never empty for long. Ministers. Bankers. Generals. Men like me. They sat in that chair and drank that wine and looked at her, at parts of her no one was ever meant to see, and they thought what I had thought.
How vulgar.
I had been embarrassed, and the embarrassment had been for me, for the indignity of having to look. I had wondered what sort of man would commission such a thing. I had not once thought of her. I had looked at a woman who had won herself in the sky and seen an object, exactly as he meant me to. In a single glance I had done to her what it had taken him a war to do. And all the while those lenses had been trained on the room from a few paces away, and if anything was still behind them, it had watched me do it.
A corpse is allowed to be mourned, and buried, and forgotten. A corpse is allowed to end. She was not. She was only allowed to be looked at, by whoever he let into the room, for as long as he lived and longer, because nothing in that case would ever rot.
I searched her face for the smallest sign. A flicker. A tightening at the corner of the mouth. I watched the lenses for any adjustment, the smallest narrowing of the aperture, the kind a camera makes when it finds its focus. They did not move. But a camera looks the same whether anything is behind it or not, and they would have looked the same whether her mind was running or long since cold. The lattice above them caught the lamplight and glittered, and I could not tell whether the glitter was reflection or thought. I found nothing. And I could not decide whether nothing meant she was gone, or meant she had decided, long ago, that stillness was the last refusal left to her.
That is the part I have never been able to put down.
The question sat in my throat like a stone. Is she still in there?
I did not ask. That too was the point. He would have answered, pleasantly and at length, and whatever the answer was, I would have had to carry it out of the room.
So I said nothing, and he smiled as though I had said something clever.
V
“Do you know why I keep her here, and not in the national museum?” he asked, returning to his chair. “The curators had a whole wing planned.”
I shook my head.
“Because everyone who negotiates with me sits in that chair, and looks at her, and thinks exactly what you are thinking now.” He lifted his glass toward the case. “She is the most persuasive member of my staff. The provinces have been very quiet. I suspect your government will find my terms more reasonable than it did this morning.”
It did. I signed everything he put in front of me. The archives record that the talks concluded ahead of schedule. They do not record that my hand shook, or that I read none of the last pages.
A prisoner exchange was annexed to the Accord. Four hundred and twelve names. I had fought three days for that annex. I did not ask for one more. It did not occur to me until I was on the train home that I could have, and by then I understood why it would have been refused. Prisoners have names on lists. Prisoners can be exchanged. She was not a prisoner. I could only have asked a man to hand over his property, and he had shown me what he thought of giving things back.
He walked me to the door with a warm hand on my back and asked me again to give his regards to my daughter. At the threshold I turned, against every instinct, and looked at the case one last time.
The eyes were on the desk, where they had always been. Where he would sit tomorrow, and the day after, and every day after that, working by the light of the lamp, while the thing that had beaten him stood open and unclothed across the room.
“I never turn the lamp off,” he said, following my gaze. “Not even at night.”
He smiled his lovely smile.
“I’d hate for her to miss anything.”
VI
The cable I sent that evening was four lines long. It reported that terms had been reached. It did not mention the display.
When his government fell, eleven years later, I made a quiet request through old channels to learn what had become of the contents of his office. The inventory listed furniture, paintings, a cellar of some distinction. It listed no glass cases. No one I asked could tell me where she had gone, and I came to understand that most of them did not know what I was asking.
Some years after that I went south myself, an old man with a cane and a borrowed car, to the airfield where the reporter had spent his week. It is a farm cooperative now. The barracks hold grain. The farmer knew why I had come before I said it, because I was not the first. He took me inside and pulled a tarpaulin from the far wall of what had been the mess hall.
The pilots had written their names there, human and synthetic together, in paint and pencil and knife-point, one above another, the way soldiers do. Someone had covered the wall the week the provinces fell, and no one had uncovered it since, except for people like me.
I found hers. Beside it, in chalk gone soft with age, someone on the ground crew had kept her tally: short bars in groups of five, the same as the stitches in her collar. In the General’s office I had not been able to bring myself to count them. I counted them there, in a grain store, with my hand on the wall. One hundred and fifty-seven. Beneath her name, in four different hands, the mechanics had signed their own, as if to say: we knew her.
One of those names was not beneath hers but beside it, close enough that the letters touched, as if whoever wrote it had wanted no space between them. I asked the farmer about it. He was quiet for a while. Then he told me it belonged to the technician who had looked after her. Not her aircraft. Her. For nineteen months every repair, every adjustment, every time she was opened and closed again had been done by the same pair of hands, and always, the farmer said, only after asking. She would let no one else touch her. Somewhere in those months the asking had become something more, and for most of them the two of them had shared a bunk. It was the technician, he said, who had nailed the tarpaulin over the wall the week the provinces fell, so that no one would paint over it. They were taken to the camps a month later. They did not come back.
I thought of the General’s men going through her memories, and of what they would have found there. A name. A face. A bunk at a particular airfield. The farmer had said a month. It is about as long, I imagine, as it takes to read a mind.
In all the hours I spent in that office, the General never once mentioned that she had been loved. He must have known. It would have been there in her memories, among the depots and the flight paths, the bunk and the hands and the voice in the dark, every bit of it read by his technicians and filed in some report. I do not think he would have called it love. I do not think he would have called it anything. It was one more item in the file, useful for exactly one thing: it told his men where to look. After that it was of no further use against the rebels, and so he had it cleared. He kept for her the memories that would hurt: the sky, the barracks, the name, the nineteen months. That one he simply threw away. If anything of her is still behind those lenses, it remembers everything it lost, except the person who loved it.
I have not written her name here. I thought about it for a long time, and I will not. He took everything else she had and put it under glass. Her name is the one thing she chose that he never touched, and it lives on a wall, where the people who used it put it. That is where it belongs.
My daughter is grown. She found the poet he recommended, years ago, on her own, and loved her. I have never told her where I first heard the name.
I keep a lamp burning in my study at night. I tell my wife it is because I sleep badly. That is true, as far as it goes.