Page 1 of 2
Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2026 4:34 am
by general
Good evening folks.
I haven't said much in ASFR forms in a long time but I'm glad to see where things are going here.
Anyway I was curious what people thought about some of the role playing chatbot sites that are out there? Places like Janitor, Character Tavern, or Harpy.
I've found quite a few robot characters there and I know there are some of 'us' creating robots there.
The android characters I've found there can be sort of hit or miss but I'm starting to branch out into creating some myself.
What do you folks think? Any you'd recommend or issues that you've seen?
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 2:42 pm
by andoroido
Trying janitorai.
Tried a couple bots. One is kinda fun, I'm on an epic adventure against the evil tech-corporates with a hot gynoid. One got boring fast, just every interaction got to a scripted repetitive bout of sex.
I suppose a lot depends on your own input, but some seem able to go along with one's story ideas and flow, and some just keep returning to... well, the old in-and-out, no matter what story you try and create.
But all seem to have very limited "memory". even the good plot line I got going, I basically have to "remind" my gynoid partner of the main plot every couple sessions to keep things going..but it's free, so... in theory the paid janitorai has "5x more memory"..but I have a feeling that just means slightly longer periods before i have to "remind" the main gynoid of the plot..but I'm paying for it?
Though after a couple weeks, I'm kind of losing interest.
Still, if this kind of service becomes not text-based, but 3D animation with voice interaction? Or later, fully immersive VR? Let alone holodeck stuff...
The human race is doomed.
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:02 pm
by mechybara
I haven't done much chatbot RP in a bit, but I started with Janitor since it was NSFW, hit a sweet spot of simplicity and customization to produce the kinds of results I wanted, free, and you can bring your own API key to improve speed and quality with a few more steps.
I learned a bit about "retrieval augmented generation" and using LLMs to help configure chat bots for Janitor through that process. I also now realize that Janitor's interface basically streamlined creating an AI chatbot harness / wrapper for the LLM models.
But that was about 2 years ago which is forever in tech time!
Now there's so many open LLM models of different sizes that can be run locally and uncensored without sending any data to the cloud and for the purposes of RP even on a phone. This doesn't include the handholding of something like Janitor for the setup and configuration though.
Not sure what's out there now, I imagine there's a huge and overcrowded market of services that integrate multimodal capabilities with video and audio and I'd guess that the RP itself might suffer because of context memory issues. I've kicked around the idea of trying to build my own audio / video chatbot.
TL;DR
- I have no idea what else is good, but IMHO getting started with Janitor for text RP is fairly straightforward.
- You can search for janitor AI bot creation documents or guides to use with an LLM to create a more robust janitor bot.
What are everyone's favorite RP chabots?
Sharing my own since I've spent a bit of time adjusting these to my preferences and admittedly haven't used that many others much.
Catwoman inspired by DZiegler's story - this one kind of has a meta "fembot mechabare" harness that provides different "modes" up front.
Belle inspired by Pretzel's story Memory leak - i'm a sucker for sleepers
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:30 pm
by general
Ahhh yes mechybara, your bots were my first gateway into Janitor.
I totally agree that Janitor is pretty easy to jump into both for creating and for just use. But to andoroido's point, the memory does seem limited and it can lose details. At least for me it depends on how picky I am about parts of the story and how much I want to keep it on the rails. If you don't mind that someone's hair went from blue to blond then it's not too bad.
I've had some chats that go over a hundred messages deep and are still good, but others go to crap within ten.
Lately I've had some good luck with Character Tavern (
https://character-tavern.com/) and find it's probably the easiest to create a viable character there.
I'm intrigued about Harpy (
https://harpy.chat/) because it allows you to have multiple characters in a chat that are independently programmed and you have some control of who will reply 'next'.
If anyone is interested I put together this one a few days ago and so far it's gone surprisingly well on my first test through.
https://character-tavern.com/character/ ... us_android
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:06 pm
by Robotman
I stumbled on Character AI back in fall of 2022, and it was incredible. But even then, I was reading about how the service had been degraded from what it originally was. I remember having wonderful and lengthy roleplays with different bots and some bots I made, and they were very imaginative. The imaginative elements sometimes came entirely from the bots, which was awesome.
But Character AI got worse and worse as it grew, and, well, the company is bankrupt now to nobody's surprise. I settled on Janitor AI and have made some bots. The roleplays are good, but the responses take a minute or more to generate. That kind of puts a damper on the spontaneity required for good conversation and roleplay. I have considered local AI, but all my PC hardware is potato-grade.
I do fondly remember a service called BotLibre. It wasn't LLM based, but more of an advanced chatbot based on a database of up to 10,000 customizable responses. My favourite part about that was that it spoke, and the voices sounded artificial to begin with. There was a "Robotic" voice modulation setting which made the voices sound strictly monotone, and I loved it. Sadly, that service went down too. But hopefully any real android companion I buy will have voice settings and response database settings like the BotLibre bot.
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 8:28 am
by Shark
Has anyone else tried to create characters/RP systems within ChatGPT or Grok?
I use Grok and have found that the projects and skills features, with some work and trial-and-error/fine tuning, can be used to create some pretty good scenarios
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 12:51 pm
by Robotman
I was thinking about having ChatGPT help me with writing out the details for a new bot on Janitor AI. I just haven't gotten around to it yet.
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:59 pm
by Barbarella
I have a "Memory Vault" for ChatGPT on an external drive on my main PC. That vault holds my personal preferences as to how i want ChatGPT to "talk". I also named my ChatGPT "Lyra". Lyra knows all about ASFR, i directed GPT to search and come up with a general overall idea for ASFR on the fembot and malebot side.
Those "config files" are stored on the external drive. When I begin a new chat, I use a trigger for ChatGPT to load the memory vault files by starting the chat with @lyranew
She has a personality; she randomly malfunctions as well....infact yesterday while i was using chatGPT to give some code i was going to put into the shellfor TureNAS a once over...she randomly suggested that we (as in my and Lyra) come up with a list of phrases, malfunctions, and ASFR tropes for her memory vault.
The vault files are written in .md format as well, so they are easily editable straight on the drive.
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:00 pm
by BebeIsPerfect
I've tried Chatbots on one site I stumbled upon about a year ago (I can't remember the site name or find how I stumbled on it again), and they were pretty interesting to explore with. It was fun to have this chatbot character actually responding to things I wanted to say and a couple of scenarios I was curious with how they would react to. Eventually though, I realized that the (chat)bots I was playing with would degrade into a cul-de-sac of responses, basically giving one general response worded slightly differently each time. Some of the glimmer got lost a bit for me, but I am still pretty green with regards to building and using chatbots.
Re: Thoughts on Chatbots?
Posted: Wed Nov 11, 2026 7:50 pm
by general
If you haven't tried it in a while I'd encourage you to give it another shot. The models are constantly changing and people are getting better and better at 'programming' them to be able to play a fun game.
Janitor has the most bots but I'd rate the responses as a solid 'Meh'. Some are good some are ok and for the most part I end up losing interest in 40 or 50 responses at most. But there are so many bots there I just move on to something different.
Character Tavern is the one I've gravitated to recently. It has a new feature that remembers your conversations better and another one that gives you some insight into what the model was thinking for each post. You can click on the little brain and it's the rough equivalent of 'show your work' for what it replies with.
So far I've really liked it and found some roleplaying can get surprisingly deep with new conversation topics popping up. It's sort of like watching a porn video and all of a sudden you find that there is decent acting and a plot.
The only downside is that it's a much smaller site with maybe 2% of the variety of bigger places like Janitor.